The Nose‑in‑It Myth
Many of us grew up seeing our parents do this to the family pet, and some of us even tried it ourselves. The idea is simple: if punishment immediately follows unwanted behaviour, your pet will learn to avoid repeating it. But for dogs and cats, it’s not that straightforward.
-
Timing matters: Studies show that any punishment must follow the unwanted behaviour within two seconds. After that, your pet can’t link the punishment to the toileting accident.
-
Confusion and fear: Punishing after a delay teaches your pet that something bad happens around that spot, not that toileting there is “wrong.” They may learn to hide accidents, avoid certain areas or people, or even become fearful of you.
Why It Sometimes Appears to “Work”
You might have tried rubbing your dog’s nose in it only to see fewer accidents afterwards. But the real reason usually isn’t the punishment itself:
-
Changed management ‑ You’re supervising more closely or confining your pet to easier‑to‑clean areas, so naturally there are fewer mishaps.
-
Age and physical maturity ‑ As your pet grows, they can physically hold their bladder/bowel for longer. A rough rule of thumb is one hour per month of age (so a 4 month‑old puppy can often manage about 4 hours between toilet breaks).
-
Routine shifts ‑ You’re taking them out more often, feeding at regular times or otherwise adjusting the schedule, all of which reduce indoor accidents.
What to Do Instead
1. Rule out health issues
If your adult dog or cat who is usually reliable starts having accidents, book a vet check. Urinary tract infections, diabetes or other medical conditions can cause sudden changes in toileting habits.
2. Establish a consistent routine
-
Frequent trips outdoors: Especially for puppies and kittens, take them out every couple of hours, after meals, naps and play sessions.
-
Praise and rewards: The instant your pet eliminates in the right spot, offer calm praise or a small treat. Positive reinforcement teaches them exactly what you want.
3. Create a “toilet zone”
Designate a specific area outside (or an indoor litter tray for cats) and guide your pet there each time. Consistency helps them learn that this is the “right” spot.
4. Supervise and confine
Use baby gates or a small pen to keep young pets within sight when you can’t directly watch them. If they start to sniff or circle, take them outside immediately.
5. Invest in training support
-
Puppy preschool (8–14 weeks): These classes teach basic toileting, socialisation and handling.
-
Intermediate or one‑on‑one training: If your pet is too old for beginner classes or needs extra help, a certified trainer can provide tailored strategies.
Putting It All Together
Toilet training takes patience, consistency and understanding of your pet’s needs ‑ not punishment. By focusing on positive reinforcement, a solid routine and ruling out medical causes, you’ll see accidents decrease and your bond grow stronger.
If you’re struggling or notice any sudden changes in your pet’s toileting habits, don’t hesitate to get in touch. I’m here to help ‑ Dr Terri’s Home Vet Visits provides compassionate, professional mobile vet care across the Sunshine Coast.
📞 Call or text Dr Terri on 0430 410 283
Never Miss a Tail-wagging Tip!
Enjoyed these training tips? Subscribe to Dr Terri's monthly newsletter for seasonal pet care advice - Delivered straight to your inbox.
Click here to Subscribe to Dr Terri's Newsletter